Sweet Treats Made with Love
Nostalgic Flavors & Decadent Memories Handcrafted from Scratch
Please allow 48 hours for all dessert orders. Pickup dates and time will be available after orders are confirmed.
Featured Treats
Peach Cobbler
A warm, spiced Southern peach cobbler made from scratch, with juicy peaches baked under an extra‑buttery, golden crust.
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies
Chewy cookies made with nutty brown butter, melty chocolate chunks, and crisp edges dusted with a hint of sea salt.
Southern Banana Pudding
Ultra‑creamy Southern banana pudding with soft vanilla wafers, fresh bananas, and a light whipped custard (no heavy pudding layer).
Nostalgia in Every Bite
Born from a love of Southern baking, Scratch & Sugar is all about the simple joy of a homemade treat. Time-honored recipes made completely from scratch, with thoughtful touches and the kind of desserts that feel like home.
Sweet Words From The Table
"REALLY GOOD! YES! THAT BANANA PUDDING WAS FIRE!"
M.M. — EVANSVILLE, IN
“The peach cobbler tasted like something straight out of my grandma’s kitchen. Warm, comforting, and absolutely delicious.”
J.R. — EVANSVILLE, IN
“The banana pudding cups disappeared in minutes at our family REUNION.”
E.M. — LEXINGTON, KY